Economic Laws and Institution

Arthur Andersen: Media Victim or Greedy Firm?

Arthur Andersen was one of the top companies in the accounting/consulting sector: international, efficient, and above all trustworthy. But its involvement in the Enron disaster has ruined it; a jury in a federal court found it guilty of obstructing justice and it is now a "zombie company" (Newsweek, 24 June 2002), having lost most of its clients.

Andersen's specific sin was the shredding of documents relating to Enron, even after Andersen officials were aware that a federal investigation into Enron's finances would be taking place. It committed other unethical acts, however, such as sanctioning Enron's very questionable accounting practices and failing to alert officials. Enron, whose rising stock value seemed to justify the free-wheeling company's daring business policies, paid Andersen $52 million in annual fees, which the accounting firm did not want to jeopardize by objecting to Enron´s deals. Andersen accuses the media of unjustified pursuit, in fact bringing about the respectable accounting firm's downfall.

Charges of unethical practices in such hitherto reputable companies as WorldCom, Merrill Lynch, ImClone, Tyco… have dominated the business news in the U.S. this summer. Congress is passing new legislation on accounting practices with harsh punishment for illegal actions, and George Bush's administration has a program to combat corporate crime and greed called "Judicial Watch." Apparently Vice-President Dick Cheney's former company Halliburton is one of the first to be caught - will it soon be Andersenized??